Looking for something different? These kitschy goldfish-shaped sugar cookies put a playful spin on a classic cut-out cookie, finished with a soft orange icing and made in a small batch perfect for sharing.

Nothing says retro bake sale magic quite like a pan of ooey-gooey Milky Way Brownies. With their fudgy base and caramel-chocolate center, these treats feel like something straight out of a 1960s church potluck.