An ongoing collection of vintage ice tray ice cream recipes, pulled from old cookbooks, recipe booklets, and the archives. I’ll be testing the old-fashioned refrigerator-freezer method one recipe at a time and adding each new flavor, its Recipe Paper Trail, and testing notes to this growing collection.

A retro soda fountain favorite, cola ice cream floats combine fizzy cola, creamy ice cream, and a cherry on top for a simple dessert drink full of old-fashioned charm.

Christmas in July. You’ll adore this old-fashioned chocolate soda with peppermint. This vintage-inspired drink recipe combines rich chocolate, refreshing peppermint, and fizzy soda for a nostalgic treat.

Step back in time with this nostalgic 1950s Jell-O Pudding Ice Cream Pie! A creamy, no-bake dessert made with instant pudding and ice cream. Perfect for retro dessert lovers.

Combine the nostalgia of your favorite childhood cereal with the indulgence of a classic ice cream sundae.

Creamy, and guilt-free diet ice cream float recipes. A lighter twist on a soda fountain classic. With zero sugar soda and carb-smart ice cream, it’s the perfect retro treat to sip on a hot day without the calories. No Sugar Root Beer + Vanilla, Lemon-Lime + Sherbet, No Sugar Cola + Chocolate, Diet Cherry Cola + Vanilla, No Sugar Ginger Ale + Pineapple Frozen Yogurt, No Sugar Cherry 7up + Vanilla low carb ice cream